This Lime Cottage Cheese Jello Salad is the kind of recipe that disappears fast at every potluck, holiday table, and family reunion it shows up at. It's cool, creamy, and set up in that classic shade of green that makes it instantly recognizable. If you've been looking for the real vintage version with crushed pineapple and walnuts, this is it.
8Ouncescrushed pineapple, 1 can, drained, juice reserved
Boiling water, as needed to make 2 cups total liquid combined with reserved pineapple juice
6OuncesLime gelatin, two 3-ounce boxes
1CupMayonnaise
1CupEvaporated milk
1CupSmall curd cottage cheese
½CupWalnuts, chopped
Instructions
Drain the crushed pineapple over a bowl and reserve the juice; set the drained pineapple aside.
Pour the reserved pineapple juice into a 2-cup liquid measuring cup, then add enough boiling water to bring the total liquid to exactly 2 cups.
Add the lime gelatin to a medium mixing bowl, then pour in the hot pineapple juice and water mixture.
Stir the gelatin mixture with a spoon for about 2 minutes, until the gelatin granules are completely dissolved and no graininess remains.
In a large mixing bowl, combine the mayonnaise and evaporated milk, and stir until the mixture is smooth and fully blended.
Slowly pour the dissolved gelatin mixture into the large mixing bowl with the mayonnaise mixture, stirring constantly until completely combined.
Add the cottage cheese, reserved crushed pineapple, and chopped walnuts to the large mixing bowl, and gently fold everything together until evenly distributed throughout the mixture.
Pour the mixture into an 8x8-inch baking dish and spread it into an even layer.
Cover the baking dish tightly with plastic wrap or a lid and refrigerate for at least 4 hours, or until the salad is completely firm and set when gently pressed in the center.
Christina's Notes
Dissolve completely: Stir the gelatin mixture for the full 2 minutes until no graininess remains — undissolved granules will affect the texture of the finished salad.
Measure liquid exactly: Bring the combined pineapple juice and boiling water to exactly 2 cups — too much liquid prevents the salad from setting up firm enough to slice.
Fold, don't stir: Add the cottage cheese, pineapple, and walnuts with a gentle folding motion to keep the mixture evenly combined without deflating it.
Set overnight: For the cleanest slices and the best flavor, refrigerate the salad overnight rather than the minimum 4 hours.
Store covered: Keep leftovers tightly covered in the refrigerator for up to 3 days — the salad holds its shape and flavor well when kept cold.
MY NOTES
NEED MORE INFO? Scan the QR code to go to the online recipe.