My Favorite Mac & Cheese

This post may contain affiliate links.  For more information, read my disclosure policy here  

There is nothing more perfect (in my 5 year old’s opinion) than macaroni and cheese.  He would eat it with everything meal — including breakfast if I let him!  It goes with everything — chicken, beef, fish, pancakes (he actually tried to convince me of that once!).

While my son loves mac and cheese from a box, he loves my homemade version even more.  Making homemade mac & cheese is not as daunting of a task as you might think.  It’s really quite simple.   And, this recipe tastes sooo much better than the stuff from a box.  Trust me on this.  Years ago I found a recipe in the Ultimate Southern Living Cookbook that seemed to work perfectly for me.  I’ve since adapted the recipe a bit to suit our tastes, and now it’s just right!

Is It a Keeper?

Mongolian pork on plate
Get Our Top 5 Quick & Easy Recipes

Get our best easy recipes delivered straight to your inbox.

Um, I think the title of this post says it all.  This is our favorite macaroni and cheese recipe.   I always use the whole grain pasta, either shells or elbows.  We actually prefer the whole grain variety over regular pasta.  And, it’s  a little more healthier than traditional pasta.

You can also play around with the cheeses.  You can snazz it up with fontina or swiss.  You can add a kick with Monterey Jack.  Or, you can keep it simple with various types of cheddar.  Just keep your cheese to about 2 cups total.  And, the trick to keeping the cheese really creamy and gooey, not grainy, is to make the cheese sauce over medium-low heat.  Resist the temptation to turn up the heat to move things along.  Just let the sauce hang out and thicken on its own.  You won’t be sorry.

If you’re feeling really adventurous, you can add veggies or mushrooms.  And, if you don’t have Panko (Japanese bread crumbs) you can use crushed Saltines.

Let’s face it, I just don’t have time to get it all together after a full day at work.  So here’s the great part…you can make this ahead of time and then bake it off when you want it!  I usually assemble mine on Sunday and then bake it during the week.  This week, we having it with meatloaf and parmesan roasted green beans!  Yum!  I can’t wait for Tuesday!

What are your favorite mac and cheese add ins?


If you like this post, be sure to stay connected by subscribing to It’s a Keeper by email!

You can also follow me on:

I’ve shared this recipe on a number of websites, blogs and recipe swaps that I’ve found. Please check out these sites on the Link & Link Parties tab above.

And, make sure to come back for my It’s a Keeper Thursday recipe and craft blog hop!

3 thoughts on “My Favorite Mac & Cheese”

  1. Tonight I learned an important lesson about my mac & cheese recipe….don’t make it in a stoneware baking dish. It’s much creamier if I make it in a regular baking dish. I think the stone sucks the moisture right out of it. Has anyone else ever noticed this happening?

  2. Macaroni and cheese is one of the best things in the world to eat. When you find your perfect recipe, it’s like heaven on Earth. 🙂


Leave a Comment