These easy Eyeball Cookies are one of my favorite easy Oreo Halloween treats. They only have a few simple ingredients and come together in minutes.
This easy Eyeball Cookies recipe requires no baking, hardly any time and very few ingredients, however, they are always a hit. They are the BEST easy Oreo Halloween recipes ever.
Love Halloween?? Try these other spooky recipes.
MORE TREAT RECIPES YOU MIGHT LIKE
Mummy Donut Bites | 15 Recipes Using Leftover Halloween Candy | Vampire Halloween Cookies
These spooky and fun treats are one of the easiest Halloween treats you can make. There are only a few simple ingredients and supplies you will need to pull this fun Halloween party treat off.
- Quick and treat: It really only takes a few minutes and they are such a hit.
- Easy Ingredients: The best kind, all premade and ready to go!
- Family Friendly: These are a hit for any age.
What You Need to Make Eyeball Cookies
Ingredients
- Oreos
- Red Gel Frosting
- Green Gel Frosting
- Blue Gel Frosting
- Dark brown M&Ms
How to Make this Easy Oreos Recipes- Step by Step
- Cookies: First, carefully, twist off the top of each Oreo cookie sandwich. You want to the filling to stay on one side of the cookie sandwich.
- Draw: Second, draw a circle with green gel frosting slightly larger than the M&M candy on half of the cookie halves that have the filling. This will be the “glue” that holds the candy in place.
- Blue: Next, draw a circle with blue gel frosting slightly larger than the M&M candy on the remaining cookie halves that have the filling. This will be the “glue” that holds the candy in place.
- Candy: Then, place M&M candies in the center of each gel frosting circle. Press lightly to ensure that the candy holds.
- Vessels: Finally, use the red gel frosting to draw on “blood vessels”.
Common Questions About Easy Oreo Cookie Recipe
Believe it or not scientist have invested a lot of time and energy into this question. Find out the answer here.
Indeed, the dark ones are great but use your imagination for this easy oreos recipes.
Of course, great for an after school snack suprise or a large party, adjust as necessary.
Although these cookies are quick to make, you can make them ahead of time and store in an airtight container until ready to serve.
Expert Tips for Making Easy Cookie Eyeballs
- Add Spiders: Use a dark icing and make a web and decorate with a candy spider.
- Short cut tip: Use candy eyeballs, like these.
- Variation tip: Feel free to add as many tips as you need in this section
- Alternate ingredient: Make with a gluten free cookie for those who cannot consume traditional Oreos.
- Cookies: Different Oreos. These are green and are great for monster eye cookies.
⭐⭐⭐ RATE THIS RECIPE ⭐⭐⭐
If you’ve tried this recipe, please rate it in the comment section below.
Oreo Eyeball Cookies
Equipment
Ingredients
- 24 Oreos
- Frosting, Red gel
- Frosting, Green gel
- Frosting, Blue gel
- 24 M&Ms, Dark Brown
Instructions
- Carefully, twist off the top of each Oreo cookie sandwich. You want to the filling to stay on one side of the cookie sandwich.
- Draw a circle with green gel frosting slightly larger than the M&M candy on half of the cookie halves that have the filling. This will be the “glue” that holds the candy in place.
- Draw a circle with blue gel frosting slightly larger than the M&M candy on the remaining cookie halves that have the filling. This will be the “glue” that holds the candy in place.
- Place M&M candies in the center of each gel frosting circle. Press lightly to ensure that the candy holds.
- Use the red gel frosting to draw on “blood vessels”.
Expert Tips
- Add Spiders: Use a dark icing and make a web and decorate with a candy spider.
- Short cut tip: Use candy eyeballs, like these.
- Variation tip: Feel free to add as many tips as you need in this section
- Alternate ingredient: Make with a gluten free cookie for those who cannot consume traditional Oreos.
- Cookies: Different Oreos. These are green and are great for monster eye cookies
Estimated Nutritional Information
The nutritional information provided are estimates. To learn more about how I calculate this information go to www.itisakeeper.com/about-its-a-keeper/privacy-disclosure-policies/
RECIPES YOU MIGHT HAVE MISSED
Get our best easy recipes delivered straight to your inbox.
Such an easy and cute idea,thank you!
It is so nice to go to your site and find easy and quick recipes for get togethers. Thanks again!
So glad you like them 🙂
nice