Must Try Pies to Finish Your Thanksgiving Feast

This post may contain affiliate links. For more information, read my full disclosure policy.  

Pie can easily be ranked as the best part of Thanksgiving. Turkey and stuffing are great, but the sweetness of pie just can’t be beat. I’ll never forget when pie time would come around when I was a kid and I got to savor it alongside my one cup of coffee for the year.

In this collection, I’ve compiled 19 pies that will perfectly finish your Thanksgiving feast. These pumpkin, pecan, apple, chocolate and creme pies will give you all the cozy fall vibes you and your family need. These recipes will be loved by everyone, even Grandma!

Old Fashioned Pumpkin Pie

A slice of pumpkin pie with a golden-brown crust and leaf-shaped pastry decorations is being lifted from the whole pie.
Image Credit: It Is a Keeper

SAVE THIS RECIPE!

Enter your email below and we’ll send this recipe straight to your inbox.

Save Recipe Final

Thanksgiving just isn’t Thanksgiving without old fashioned pumpkin pie. The creamy pumpkin flavor will remind you of fond memories from your childhood. Serve with whipped cream or a scoop of ice cream if you like your pie a bit less rich.

GET THIS RECIPE: Old Fashioned Pumpkin Pie

▶️ WANT MORE EASY RECIPES? Get our 5 Best Super Fast Supper recipes delivered straight to your inbox.

Easy Apple Pie with Crumb Topping

A slice of apple crumble pie on a white plate, with a green apple and another plate partially visible in the background.
Image Credit: It Is a Keeper

Easy apple pie with crumb topping is an easy way to impress your family or friends when Thanksgiving dessert comes around. This apple pie will take the stress out of Thanksgiving preparation with only 8 ingredients and a prep time of 10 minutes. Your guests will love this pie and its crumb topping, especially if served with ice cream.

GET THIS RECIPE: Easy Apple Pie with Crumb Topping

▶️ WANT MORE EASY RECIPES? Get our 5 Best Super Fast Supper recipes delivered straight to your inbox.

Pecan Pie Tarts

Mini pecan pies with a crumbly topping are cooling on a black wire rack over a white surface.
Image Credit: It Is a Keeper

What’s better than normal sized pie? Mini pie! Pecan pie tarts are a mini version of the beloved Thanksgiving classic. These tarts are perfect for when you only have a little bit of room in your stomach after an amazing dinner.

GET THIS RECIPE: Pecan Pie Tarts

▶️ WANT MORE EASY RECIPES? Get our 5 Best Super Fast Supper recipes delivered straight to your inbox.

Butterfinger Pie (No Bake)

A slice of Butterfinger cream pie with a nutty topping, drizzled with chocolate and caramel sauce, served on a patterned plate.
Image Credit: It Is a Keeper

Butterfinger pie is a chocolatey and nutty pie that’s perfect for experienced and new bakers alike. This is no-bake pie comes together in 10 minutes and is made with only 4 ingredients. Your Thanksgiving guests will love Butterfinger pie’s creamy, chocolate goodness.

GET THIS RECIPE: Butterfinger Pie (No Bake)

▶️ WANT MORE EASY RECIPES? Get our 5 Best Super Fast Supper recipes delivered straight to your inbox.

Turtle Brownie Pie

A slice of turtle brownie pie topped with whipped cream, chopped pecans, and chocolate drizzle, being lifted from a dish that contains the rest of the pie.
Image Credit: It Is a Keeper

Turtle brownie pie is great for both pie and brownie lovers. Its incredibly rich, irresistible filling is made with brownie mix, pecans, chocolate chips and caramel sauce, which is enveloped in a gorgeous Oreo crust. Bring a big taste of chocolate to the Thanksgiving table with this awesome pie.

GET THIS RECIPE: Turtle Brownie Pie

▶️ WANT MORE EASY RECIPES? Get our 5 Best Super Fast Supper recipes delivered straight to your inbox.

No Bake Caramel Pie

A slice of no bake caramel pie filled with a thick layer of dulce de leche and whipped topping and pieces of Milky Way chocolate candy on top, served on a white plate.
Image Credit: It Is a Keeper

No bake caramel pie combines dulce de leche and Milky Way bars for a caramel enthusiast’s delight. This pie is another easy way to impress guests as it uses 5 ingredients and your refrigerator does most of the work.

GET THIS RECIPE: No Bake Caramel Pie

▶️ WANT MORE EASY RECIPES? Get our 5 Best Super Fast Supper recipes delivered straight to your inbox.

Old Fashioned Coconut Cream Pie

A slice of creamy coconut pie topped with whipped cream, chocolate and coconut shavings is held up on a metal spatula.
Image Credit: It Is a Keeper

Old fashioned coconut cream pie is a creamy classic that will fit right in at Thanksgiving. It features custard and meringue for a perfect coconut flavor. Savor it while you can because there’s sure to be few, if any, leftovers.

GET THIS RECIPE: Old Fashioned Coconut Cream Pie

▶️ WANT MORE EASY RECIPES? Get our 5 Best Super Fast Supper recipes delivered straight to your inbox.

Double Layer Cream Cheese Pumpkin Pie

A slice of double layered cream cheese and pumpkin pie with a dollop of whipped cream on top is served on a white plate. The bottom layer is the cream cheese layer and the top layer is the pumpkin.
Image Credit: It Is a Keeper

Double layer cream cheese pumpkin pie is a multi-layer magic trick in your mouth. It’s decadent, with a cream cheese layer on the bottom and a pumpkin layer on top. Plus it’s no bake and takes only 15 minutes to prepare.

GET THIS RECIPE: Double Layer Cream Cheese Pumpkin Pie

▶️ WANT MORE EASY RECIPES? Get our 5 Best Super Fast Supper recipes delivered straight to your inbox.

Mini Apple Pie Bites

Close-up of baked mini apple bites dusted with cinnamon and sugar, arranged on a white surface
Image Credit: It Is a Keeper

Mini apple pie bites work well for Thanksgiving diners that don’t want to commit to just one dessert. They are the perfect bite size treat for apple pie on the go. Mini apple pie bites are great for people who enjoy the fall combo of apple and cinnamon.

GET THIS RECIPE: Mini Apple Pie Bites

▶️ WANT MORE EASY RECIPES? Get our 5 Best Super Fast Supper recipes delivered straight to your inbox.

No Bake Pumpkin Pie Cheesecake

A slice of creamy no bake pumpkin pie cheesecake with a golden crust, topped with whipped cream, chopped walnuts, and a sprinkle of ground spice.
Image Credit: It Is a Keeper

No bake pumpkin pie cheese cake is a scrumptious cheesecake twist on a classic Thanksgiving pumpkin pie. Plus, it’s beginner friendly. All you need to do is combine the pumpkin, spices, sugar, cream cheese, and whipped topping and scoop it into a graham cracker crust.

GET THIS RECIPE: No Bake Pumpkin Pie Cheesecake

No Bake Orange Pie

A slice of no bake orange pie with a graham cracker crust, topped with whipped cream and a mandarin orange segment, on a white plate.
Image Credit: It Is a Keeper

Your inner child and any little guests will adore this no bake orange pie made with mandarin oranges, Jello, and Cool Whip. Orange pie is creamy and citrusy, a refreshing taste for after your Thanksgiving feast.

GET THIS RECIPE: No Bake Orange Pie

No Bake Butterscotch Cinnamon Pie

A slice of creamy no bake butterscotch cinnamon pie topped with caramel sauce and pecans is served on a white plate with a fork beside it.
Image Credit: It Is a Keeper

Butterscotch and cinnamon might not be the first things you think of when considering Thanksgiving and fall flavors, but I can promise you that No Bake Butterscotch Cinnamon Pie screams autumn. This dessert is like if butter pecan ice cream was a fluffy, caramel-coated pie. This light pie will perfectly finish off Thanksgiving dinner.

GET THIS RECIPE: No Bake Butterscotch Cinnamon Pie

Caramel Pear Pie

A lattice-topped caramel pear pie in a glass pie dish, with a slice removed and a spoon resting in the empty space.
Image Credit: Sally’s Baking

Caramel Pear Pie combines, you guessed it, caramel and pears for a beautifully delicious Thanksgiving dessert. It also features cinnamon to enhance the fall flavor. This pie is silky and buttery, a great compliment to Thanksgiving dinner.

GET THIS RECIPE: Caramel Pear Pie

Homemade Cherry Pie (With Thick Filling)

A slice of cherry pie topped with a scoop of vanilla ice cream on a white plate.
Image Credit: Sally’s Baking

This homemade cherry pie with thick filling has a hints of almond and vanilla flavor and won’t ooze out when you cut it. It may seem daunting to make a pie from scratch, but this recipe makes it extremely easy. Your Thanksgiving guests will recognize this as the best cherry pie they’ve ever had.

GET THIS RECIPE: Homemade Cherry Pie (With Thick Filling)

Nutella Swirled Pumpkin Pie

A marble pie with Nutella and pumpkin swirls, partially sliced, in a glass pie dish on a wooden surface.
Image Credit: Sally’s Baking

Nutella swirled pumpkin pie is like a warm pumpkin, hazelnut, chocolate hug. This pie features a gingersnap crust that pairs great with the pumpkin for that pop of fall spice in your mouth.

GET THIS RECIPE: Nutella Swirled Pumpkin Pie

Peach Bourbon Pie

A slice of bourbon peach pie topped with a scoop of vanilla ice cream on a white plate with a fork.
Image Credit: Gimme Some Oven

Peach bourbon pie is cozy, a tiny bit boozy, and just right for Thanksgiving. Even better, it’s vegan for you or any vegan family members. Your Thanksgiving guests will never forget this.

GET THIS RECIPE: Peach Bourbon Pie

Apple Cranberry Pie

A slice of lattice-topped apple cranberry pie on a white decorative plate, garnished with cranberries and a fork beside it.
Image Credit: Sally’s Baking

Apple cranberry pie helps transition Thanksgiving into Christmastime like Santa Claus at the end of the Macy’s parade. You’ll fall in love with this magical combination of fall and winter fruits zested with a bit of orange. This pie is also a way to incorporate the essence of the Thanksgiving dinner side dish of cranberry sauce into dessert.

GET THIS RECIPE: Apple Cranberry Pie

Brown Sugar Peach Crumble Pie

A slice of peach crumble pie topped with a scoop of vanilla ice cream on a wooden plate with a fork
Image Credit: Sally’s Baking

Brown sugar peach crumble pie is kind of like peach pie and a snickerdoodle had a baby. The topping is filled with brown sugar and cinnamon while the filling is bursting with sweet, tender peaches. You won’t have a hard time convincing Grandma to bake this one this Thanksgiving.

GET THIS RECIPE: Brown Sugar Peach Crumble Pie

Snickers Apple Pie

An apple Snickers pie with a graham cracker crust, creamy filling, topped with chopped Snickers chocolate candy bars and drizzled caramel sauce. Green apples and caramel sauce create the perfect backdrop for this holiday dessert.
Image Credit: I Heart Naptime

Snickers apple pie is basically a chocolate caramel apple in pie form. No baking is required for this dish. Just combine apples, caramel, snickers, Cool Whip, cream cheese, and powdered sugar for a bit of the county fair at your Thanksgiving table.

GET THIS RECIPE: Snickers Apple Pie

▶️ WANT MORE EASY RECIPES? Get our 5 Best Super Fast Supper recipes delivered straight to your inbox.

Want More Easy Recipes Like This?

A cover page titled "Ultimate List of Dinner Ideas" is placed on top of several recipe lists, featuring a baked casserole in a red dish.

Meet Christina

Woman in red blouse slicing lemons in a kitchen setting.

Hi there, it’s nice to meet you!  I’m a recipe developer, author, TV contributor and recipe hoarder that shares tried and true recipes anyone can make.  It Is a Keeper started in 2010 as a hobby that quickly grew.  Spending time in the kitchen has always made me happy – whether I’m making an old favorite that I know by heart or trying a new recipe. You can learn more about me here. 

Leave a Comment